featured.jpg

A 3.5 Percent Raise Budget Will Not Keep Your Best People

By The Riderflex Team

Budget season is here, and the pay numbers are in. The Conference Board’s annual survey puts the median 2027 salary increase budget for US companies at 3.5 percent, the same as this year. WTW projects 3.4 percent. Payscale and Mercer land in the same neighborhood. Nobody is planning a big year, and nobody is planning a freeze.

On paper that looks like stability. In practice it is a squeeze, and most leadership teams will not feel it until a key person resigns in March.

Where the money actually goes

The headline number hides the problem. In the Conference Board data, merit budgets sit around 3.1 percent. The bucket for everything else, the market adjustments, pay equity fixes, retention moves, and premiums for hard-to-find skills, is about half a percent.

Half a percent is not a strategy. It is a rounding error that has to cover every person in the company whose pay has drifted below what the market would offer them today.

And that drift is real. Payscale’s survey found that about a quarter of companies said they lost people this year because pay increases were not enough. That is not a forecast. That is what already happened.

The quiet math of the even raise

When budgets are tight, the easy move is to give everyone roughly the same increase. It feels fair, it avoids hard conversations, and it keeps the spreadsheet simple. Payscale reports that fewer companies are planning these across-the-board raises for 2027, and for good reason.

Here is what an even raise does in practice. Your average performer, who may not have many outside options, gets 3.5 percent and stays. Your strongest people, the ones recruiters call every month, get the same 3.5 percent and start listening.

You end up paying to keep the people who were going to stay anyway while underpaying the ones who can leave. Over a couple of cycles, that is how a solid team slowly turns into an average one.

Compression is the hidden cost

There is a second problem that shows up the moment you hire. To land a strong new person, you will usually have to pay close to today’s market rate. If your existing team has been getting modest raises for three years, the new hire can walk in earning as much as, or more than, the people who will train them.

People find out. They always do. And when a tenured high performer learns the new person makes more, you have a retention problem that no merit increase will fix.

Before you open a search for a critical role, look at what you pay the people already doing similar work. If the gap is wide, fix some of it first or plan for the conversation. Hiring someone new at market while ignoring the team you already have is one of the fastest ways to lose both.

What to do with a tight budget

You cannot conjure more money, but you can spend what you have with more intent.

Name your critical few. Identify the small set of roles where a departure would hurt revenue, operations, or customers, and the people in them. Start there.

Check them against the market now, not after they resign. A counteroffer costs more and works less often than a proactive adjustment.

Differentiate on purpose. A solid raise for your top people and a smaller one for others is fairer than it sounds. Pay should reflect impact, not just tenure.

Use the levers that are not base pay. Title, scope, flexibility, development, and a clear path forward all matter. They do not replace pay, but they can close part of the gap.

Tell people the truth. If the budget is tight, say so and explain how decisions were made. People handle a modest raise far better than a mystery.

Hire for the long run

The other side of this is hiring. When raise budgets are flat, every hire you make has to be someone worth keeping for years, not someone you will be replacing in 18 months because the fit was off.

That is where a careful process earns its keep. At Riderflex, every candidate we present has been vetted through a C-level video interview and assessed for culture fit, not just a skills match on paper. Our boutique model means we spend real time understanding your team, your pay structure, and what it will actually take to land and keep the right person. It is a big part of why we have earned hundreds of five-star Google reviews from clients and candidates.

The bottom line

A 3.5 percent budget is not the problem. Spreading it evenly and hoping your best people do not notice is. Spend the money where it protects the business, fix compression before it bites, and make every new hire someone you want around for the long haul.

If you are planning key hires for 2027 and want a partner who understands both the market and the math, we are glad to talk. For more on hiring the right way, check out the Riderflex podcast and Steve Urban’s book, The Riderflex Guide.

https://www.riderflex.com | 888-964-5876 | info@riderflex.com

Photo: Mimi Thian on Unsplash